Happy Friday and happy Release Day for the Burnt Offering EP! It’s available on all your favorite streaming platforms. What is it, you may ask? Let’s call them variations on a theme. The theme is a song off my first full-length album, Creature Comforts. Let’s explore each version included in the five-song set.
- Burnt Offering (Version 1): Originally intended for Creature Comforts, it got left off because…well, I’m not really sure. Maybe we weren’t totally happy with the mix? Maybe my vocals? It’s been a minute, so who can recall. But it’s the first song I ever recorded without an acoustic guitar. Yup, no Martin in this one! Just the G&L ASAT on this one, baby!
- Burnt Offering (Version 2): This one did show up on Creature Comforts! I think this song turned out as good as it did all because of Clyde’s mixing; the version I sent him just all the instruments playing all the time, but he took what was there and crafted it into a great piece of songcraft.
- Burnt Offering (Demo 1): The original demo for this song had all of the bits that ended up in the final version: all the words are written, all the chords are there, everything is in the correct order and all. But apparently I had not yet designated a chunk of it as a repeating chorus, and the chord changes happen much faster in this version than in any of the others. I must’ve also forgotten I ever did this version because I ended up doing a second demo just a few months later. I find the iterative process of songwriting to be a fascinating thing, so it’s kind of fun to go back and hear what could have been with this song.
- Burnt Offering (Demo 2): Speaking of, here’s that second demo. Everything is played in the correct order, correct chord structure and change rhythm, there’s even an actual chorus now! And some lunatic tried to record a very rough, improvised lead part over the whole thing that was ultimately left out of the final versions (though I think I did adopt a little tiny bit of it here and there in Version 1).
- Burnt Offering (Fancy Version): So late last year, as he was preparing songs for his own Gray Charlies EP, my brother happened to pick Burnt Offering as one of the songs he wanted to do a new version of. He didn’t tell me anything about it at first, just went about getting his hired musicians to perform their parts so he could assemble them all mad scientist style at the end. The Gray Charlies version does sound really good, even if the way the woman sings it on that one has kinda crept into how I sing it now. But somewhere along the way, the string quartet he hired to perform on the song used my Version 2 as their template, and I am not well-known for being a consistent rhythm keeper. Which means as a track he could use, it was useless – all the other musicians were following a set rhythm and tempo that this strings track did not. It did, however, mean we could come up with this fancy version of the song for me, which I’ve been sitting on for the past, like, five months now. It makes me feel very fancy.
Anyway, there you have it. Thanks as always to Brother Cylde for mixing and mastering all my stuff and managing to make me sound like I might actually know what I’m doing.